We Are All the Same in the Dark, a Fiction Review
Book cover image from Amazon
In We Are All the Same in the Dark by Julia Heaberlin, ten haunting years have passed since Trumanell Branson disappeared, leaving behind nothing but a smear of blood and a town suspended in yearning.
Her crowned and ghostly presence endures — gracing church foyers, police station walls, and high school hallways — each faded poster whispering a solemn promise: “We will find you”. But in Heaberlin’s unsettling portrait of a town unable to move on, time has frayed more than memories.
Trumanell’s brother, Wyatt, once an ordinary local boy, now drifts through life as a pariah, marooned in the crumbling remains of their family home. Though legally he hasn’t been charged, he’s imprisoned by rumors and the relentless glare of a true-crime documentary that refuses to release its grip.
When Wyatt discovers a silent girl abandoned in a meadow of dandelions, alert and unblinking, he sees not just a mystery, but a message. To Odette Tucker, the town’s youngest cop, the girl is a spark — an uncanny echo of another girl long lost. Odette cannot turn away, not when the stranger’s quiet strength mirrors her own.
Both bear scars — Odette’s literal and invisible, the girl’s hidden behind silence and a gaze that misses nothing. Their disabilities are not signs of weakness, but sharpened instruments of perception — tools that let them see what others overlook, feel what others dismiss, endure what others could not.
As Odette races to unearth the truth buried in both the girl’s past and her own, she is drawn deeper into the town’s mythology — a story steeped in secrets, fear, and violence. What happened the night Trumanell disappeared? What still breathes beneath the surface?
In We Are All The Same in The Dark, Julia Heaberlin offers more than a thriller. It is a great choice for readers drawn to atmospheric suspense and emotional complexity.
She gives us heroines who turn limitations into power, who prove that strength isn’t always loud, and beauty isn’t always seen with both eyes. Their journey is one of haunting suspense and quiet revolution, and in the dark, they shine.
This novel offers a haunting and lyrical blend of psychological suspense and Southern Gothic, with a slow-burn mystery that is less about the whodunit and more about the unsettling echoes left behind. This isn’t just another crime thriller — it’s a deeply character-driven exploration of trauma, resilience, and the stories we tell ourselves to survive.
Reading it felt like standing in a field under a wide Texas sky just before a storm breaks: eerie, quiet, and tense with unspoken things. Heaberlin’s prose pulses with elegy and intimacy — flashes of poetry wrapped around grit, each sentence breathing rawness and grace onto the page.
We Are All The Same in The Dark weaves through multiple perspectives, primarily those of Odette Tucker, a cop missing part of her leg and still haunted by the case of a long-missing girl, and later, a mysterious non-verbal teenager named Angel who arrives like an unanswered question.
The novel dismantles the myth of the “perfect victim” with quiet precision, drawing me into its unflinching critique of how society diminishes women — especially those who are young, troubled, or inconvenient. It’s not fast-paced, but it pulses with quiet urgency, and the payoff is less about shocking twists than the aching sadness of truth slowly unearthed.
I strongly recommend We Are All The Same in The Dark to readers who appreciate nuanced psychological thrillers with an emotional undercurrent. It’s also ideal for those who love stories where the setting is nearly a character itself.We Are All The Same in The Dark is best suited for mature teens and adults — mainly due to its emotional depth, darker themes, and depictions of trauma. It’s not overly graphic, but it lingers in the best, most haunting way.
Need more great reads? Check these out!
- Sealfinger, Doggerland, & Sandraker – Mystery series Book Review
- Mimi Lee Cracks the Code – Cozy Mystery Book Review
- The Night Library at Sternendach – A Dark Poetry Book Review
- Dark Fiction Book Review: Extasia
- Where the Dead Sleep, a Book Review
- The Crimson Crown, a Dark Fiction Review
- The Gold Persimmon – A Dark Novel Review
Karrie Wortner
Karrie Wortner (she/her) is a storyteller driven by wanderlust and a passion for life’s unscripted moments. She captures the richness of human experience through photography and writing, believing in the power of words and images to inspire and connect. A devoted wife and mother, she finds joy in shared traditions and everyday beauty. With a background in psychology and working toward a BFA in Writing and Applied Arts at UWGB, she contributes to The Teaching Press, The Quill, and Northern Lights. Her expertise in publishing and media helps her craft narratives that spark curiosity, foster understanding, and celebrate diverse perspectives.
Find more of her work in her portfolio, and follow her on LinkedIn.
1 Comment
[…] We Are All the Same in the Dark – Book Review […]